The people we were supposedly defending in fact hated us because we destroyed their forests with chemical defoliants, burned their fields with napalm, flattened their villages with pound bombs, and called them gooks, chinks, slopes, dinks, and zipperheads, turning their sons into shoeshine boys and their daughters into whores.
In effect, senior Bush was saying to the grand strategists in the White House and Pentagon that the role of American Military lessons learned from vietnam power was again available for use around the world.
Three million people were killed in a War against a country that had never attacked the U. The United States gets in big trouble when the "marketplace of ideas" breaks down and when the public and our leadership do not have an open debate about what to do. Are there any lessons the U. And that means that sometimes our forces will go over the line, as they did in Haditha or Abu Ghraib.
Not only the regionally destabilising outcome - including the blowback effect of perversely adding weight to Iran's overall diplomatic influence - but the reputational costs in the Middle East associated with an imprudent, destructive and failed military intervention make the Iraq War the worst American foreign policy disaster since its defeat in Vietnam in the s.
The United States recognized the village as an integral part in its counterinsurgency plans at a very early stage, but ultimately failed in executing such plans properly. Once it becomes clear that we face a lengthy and messy struggle, the American people quite properly begin to ask why we are pouring billions of dollars and thousands of lives into some strategic backwater.
More broadly, counterinsurgency warfare involving a core encounter between Western invading and occupying forces and a national resistance movement will not be decided on the basis of hard power military superiority. The secularism and middle-class character of Iraqi society was overrated.
The truly "fatal mistake" made by Petraeus, Galula Military lessons learned from vietnam all the counterinsurgency advocates who have followed this path, is the failure to recognise that when the American military and its allies attack and occupy a non-Western country - especially in the Islamic world - and start dividing, killing and policing its inhabitants, popular resistance will be mobilised.
Todd South Marine Col. As usual, there was not a solitary military-age male there. Indeed, throughout this hand guide designed for the U. US seeks new phase in relations with Vietnam The flag-draped coffins of dead young Americans were shown on TV, leading defence hawks to contend somewhat ridiculously that "the war was lost in American living rooms".
There is a great deal that seldom gets mentioned about American history. This goal is understandable and even laudable, but it does not necessarily follow that better pre-war planning would have produced a better result. In China in I helped see to it that Standard Oil went its way unmolested.
For starters, there were extensive pre-war plans for occupying and rebuilding Iraq; the problem was that key decisionmakers e. And they are right. The Geneva agreement that had negotiated the French departure explicitly stated that there was to be no division of the country.
This view ignores the fact that the Bush administration negotiated the Status of Forces agreement that set the timetable for U. This post-attack failure was compounded by the fact that the UN lent support to the unlawful American-led occupation that followed.
The lesson was learned too late to apply it on a large scale in Vietnam, but the Reagan administration applied the principle to its wars in Central America, spending millions of dollars a day to crush popular revolutions in El Salvador and Nicaragua with only a tiny handful of American lives lost in the process.
Army, there are numerous references to lessons learned from the Vietnam War. As folk singer Bob Dylan instructed us long ago, the answer is "blowin' in the wind", or in more straightforward language, the reasons for such impunity conferred upon the American and British leaders is a crude display of geopolitics - their countries were not defeated and occupied, their governments never surrendered, and such strategic failures or successes are exempted from legal scrutiny.
Ultimately, by the late s, the United States began to accept the reality that it could no longer continue its involvement in the Vietnam War. Common Dreams is not your normal news site.
Should such a record of involvement have any adverse consequences? Because it is not clear if any U. Inthe U.
This became key inwhen the Gulf of Tonkin incident occurred. Marine base at Khe Sanh. Social and Political Student protests were fueled by fur because "draft policies largely exempted college students and men with critical civilian skills, the armed forces in Vietnam were largely composed of the least privileged young Americans.
Iraq alone will end up costing the U. He is currently pursuing a B. Routledge, And in my fourteen years at this school, not one of my students—now numbering in the hundreds after so many years—has chosen to forego college and enlist in the US military instead.
It is only when we witness the dismantling of many of America's plus acknowledged foreign military bases spread around the world, and see the end of repeated US military intervention globally, that we can have some hope that the correct lessons of the Iraq War are finally being learned.
Another lesson from Iraq and Afghanistan is that local identities remain quite powerful and foreign occupations almost always trigger resistance, especially in cultures with a history of heavy-handed foreign interference.
It is therefore unsurprising that U. For while this transformation of the veteran from unwitting perpetrator to American hero was taking place, US policymakers were slowly but surely reasserting US military intervention as a legitimate and necessary instrument of foreign policy.The American military and leadership appear to have learned some lessons from our involvement in the Vietnam War.
This paper will discuss the lessons learned from the following arenas: diplomatic negotiations, presidential leadership, and cultural/social contexts.
Sep 16, · There are two great lessons of Vietnam that the Trump administration might bear in mind before attempting to reprise the stalemate strategy that so conspicuously failed in the earlier conflict.
The Army even had a history about learning lessons learned. The post-Gulf War learning, however, was a somewhat perverse variation of what had gone on in the s. VIETNAM: LESSONS LEARNED OUTLINE Thesis Statement. The U.S.
civilian and military leadership failed to heed the lessons of the past during the Vietnam war. They understimated the enemy and the. As a result, General Maxwell D. Taylor, the Eighth Army’s last wartime commander (and later chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff during the Vietnam War), complained that ‘there was no thoroughgoing analysis ever made of the lessons to be learned from Korea, and later policy makers proceeded to repeat many of the same mistakes.’.
8 Essential Lessons We Learned From the Vietnam Antiwar Movement Many different lessons of Vietnam were considered at the Washington event. More military spending means increasing budget.Download